Asking Employees for a Doctor’s Note

When you’re starting to drown between employee concerns, payroll duties and helping your CEO -- HR Insider is there to help get the logistical work out of the way.

Need a policy because of a recent regulatory change? We’ve got it for you. Need some quick training on a specific HR topic? We’ve got it for you. HR Insider provides the resources you need to craft, implement and monitor policies with confidence. Our team of experts (which includes lawyers, analysts and HR professionals) keep track of complex legislation, pending changes, new interpretations and evolving case law to provide you with the policies and procedures to keep you ahead of problems. FIND OUT MORE...

Favorite Print Email

QUESTION:

When can you ask an employee for a doctor’s note? Specifically, can you ask for a doctor’s note to pay out a sick day?

ANSWER:

Yes. Here’s a quick summary of the ground rules for doctor’s notes. (Click on the link for more information and Model Tools about the particular item.)

EXPLANATION:

General Rule: Under privacy laws, you can’t collect medical information about an individual without the person’s consent. Exception: Employers are allowed to collect medical information about their employees when it’s reasonably necessary to carry out essential employment functions, including via asking for a doctor’s note. Examples:

You CAN Ask for a Doctor’s Note:

To confirm that an employee who calls in sick really is sick and thus entitled to sick pay;
To confirm that an employee in an attendance management program who calls in sick really is sick;
To confirm that employees required to undergo rehab, anger management and other employment-related treatment plans are following the terms of those programs;
To verify that an employee who claims disability under the organization’s disability plan really has a disabling injury;
To confirm that an employee who requests an unpaid medical leave of absence really has an illness for which leave is allowed or required;
To confirm that an employee requesting accommodation for a medical condition really has such a condition; and/or
To determine an ill or injured employee’s capabilities during the return-to-work process.

Conversely, asking employees for a doctor’s note isn’t allowed when there’s no employment-related justification to have that information. Examples:

You CAN’T Ask for a Doctor’s Note:

As a matter of course or principle any time an employee calls in sick;
To harass the employee; and
To confirm a suspicion that an employee is hiding an illness when she claims she’s fine.

Information You Can & Can’t Ask for

Even when it’s justifiable to ask for a doctor’s note, you must ask only for minimum amount of information needed to meet your employment-related purpose.

TODAY’S EXPERT
	*Glenn Demby* is a lawyer and contributor of HR Insider.

In cases of short absences due to illness, you don’t have a right to insist on any details about the employee’s condition. A one sentence note from the doctor stating that “Employee X is sick” is generally enough.

Even in cases where an employee’s medical condition is relevant to the employment-related purpose, e.g., during the return-to-work or accommodation process, there are limits to the medical information you can request.

The basic rule: You can ask the doctor for the employee’s prognosis but not diagnosis, i.e., when she can return but not what condition she actually has.