Tagged: medical leave
-
AuthorPosts
-
Forum: Private
Hello,
We are a non-union company in BC, there is a manager going through personal issues that is affecting his work performance. We want to know what we can do as an employer:
1. Can we mandate he seek/use the free counselling platform available?
2. Can we mandate a medical leave?Thanks for your help.
In British Columbia, as a non-union employer, you have the right to address a manager’s ongoing performance concerns, even where those concerns appear to be connected to personal difficulties. However, you need to balance your responsibility to maintain workplace performance standards with your obligations under the BC Human Rights Code, particularly the duty to accommodate employees who may have a disability, including a mental health-related disability. I would recommend approaching this as both a performance management matter and a potential accommodation matter, rather than assuming that the employee’s personal circumstances automatically excuse the performance issues.
1. Can you mandate that he seek or use the free counselling platform? Generally, no. You can strongly encourage the manager to access the company’s Employee Assistance Program (EAP) or free counselling platform, explain the resources available, and offer support in accessing them. However, requiring an employee to participate in counselling or disclose information about their counselling sessions would generally be inappropriate. Counselling is a voluntary and confidential process, and an employer should be cautious about directing an employee to undergo treatment without a legitimate legal or occupational basis. You can, however, clearly communicate that the employee is expected to meet the performance requirements of their position and that the company is willing to support them in doing so.
2. Can you mandate a medical leave? You cannot simply force an employee to take a medical leave because they are experiencing personal difficulties or their performance is declining. However, there may be circumstances where you have legitimate concerns about the employee’s fitness to perform their job, particularly if their behaviour or performance raises health and safety concerns or suggests a possible underlying medical condition. In these circumstances, you may have a duty to inquire about whether a medical issue is contributing to the performance concerns. You may also be justified in requesting medical documentation or a fitness-for-work assessment to understand whether the employee can safely perform their duties and whether workplace accommodations are required. Depending on the circumstances, a temporary leave pending clarification of fitness for work may be appropriate, but this should be approached cautiously and with legal guidance.
My recommendation would be to arrange a confidential meeting with the manager to discuss the specific performance concerns, explain the impact they are having on the business, and ask whether there is anything affecting his ability to perform his role for which he may require workplace support or accommodation. You do not need to ask for details about his personal circumstances or request a diagnosis. If a potential medical or mental health issue is identified, engage in the accommodation process and request only the medical information reasonably necessary to understand his restrictions, limitations and expected duration. If no accommodation is required, or performance concerns remain despite reasonable accommodation, you can continue with your normal performance management process. I would also recommend consulting an employment lawyer before mandating leave or taking disciplinary action, given the potential human rights implications.
-HRInsider Staff
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.