Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 31 through 45 (of 264 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • Haley O’Halloran
    Keymaster
      Post count: 264

      Based on the circumstances described, proceeding with a without-cause termination, paying the employee their minimum entitlements under Ontario’s Employment Standards Act, 2000 (ESA), and amending the Record of Employment to reflect the termination is a reasonable step. The ESA payment should be provided unconditionally and should include all required termination pay, vacation pay and benefits continuation for the statutory notice period. Any amount offered beyond the ESA minimum in exchange for a release should remain clearly separate from these statutory entitlements.

      It is important to recognize, however, that paying the ESA minimum does not necessarily eliminate the employee’s potential constructive or wrongful dismissal claim. Because the original employment agreement apparently did not contain a temporary layoff provision and the employee has expressly reserved their right to pursue constructive dismissal, there may still be potential common-law notice exposure. The earlier offer of four weeks does not limit that exposure unless the employee signs a valid release.

      The employer should also ensure that the termination documentation and amended ROE accurately reflect the sequence of events. Care should be taken not to suggest that the employer is admitting the temporary layoff amounted to constructive dismissal or that the termination is occurring because the employee objected to the layoff. The termination should instead be documented as a without-cause decision, with a clear and consistent effective date.

      All relevant records should be retained, including the employment agreement, communications regarding the loss of customer work, the temporary layoff notice, the employee’s objection, the settlement offer and deadline extension, payroll calculations, benefits information, the original and amended ROEs, and the final termination communication. The employer should also confirm that there are no other statutory issues that could affect the termination, such as mass termination requirements, protected leaves, accommodation obligations or potential reprisal concerns.

      Given that this situation involves a disputed temporary layoff, a potential constructive dismissal claim and possible common-law notice obligations, it requires more individualized legal analysis than can appropriately be provided through a general question-and-answer forum. I recommend that the employer refer this matter to qualified Ontario employment legal counsel for review of the employment agreement, termination date, potential liability and final termination documentation, and direct any further questions on this specific matter to legal counsel.

      I hope this helps and wish you well!
      -HRInsider Staff

      Haley O’Halloran
      Keymaster
        Post count: 264

        In Ontario, ADHD can fall within the disability protections of the Ontario Human Rights Code, so the employer should treat the disclosure as triggering a duty to inquire into and explore accommodation. That does not mean that legitimate performance expectations must be abandoned. The Ontario Human Rights Commission (OHRC) recognizes that employees with disabilities are expected to meet agreed-upon performance standards once appropriate accommodation is provided. Before escalating performance consequences, however, the employer should make reasonable efforts to determine whether the missed deadlines, attendance issues, or other performance concerns are disability-related and whether accommodation could enable the employee to meet the essential requirements of the position.

        At this stage, I would recommend continuing the accommodation process and performance-management process in parallel, rather than waiting indefinitely for medical documentation. Meet with the employee and explain that there are specific, ongoing performance concerns—using objective examples such as missed reports, deadlines, and deliverables—and that the goal is to help them succeed. Because ADHD has been disclosed, ask whether any of these difficulties are connected to disability-related limitations and what workplace supports may help. You can follow up on the medical documentation, but frame the request around functional limitations, restrictions, ability to perform essential duties, and accommodation needs, rather than asking the physician for detailed diagnostic information. The OHRC also says employers should actively investigate possible solutions and, where appropriate, consider interim accommodation based on the information available rather than simply waiting for a medical assessment.

        A collaborative PIP can therefore be appropriate, provided it is clearly about the employee’s job requirements rather than their ADHD. Identify the essential deliverables, reasonable deadlines and measurable standards; ask the employee what barriers are contributing to the gaps; and jointly consider supports such as clearer written priorities, intermediate milestones, scheduled check-ins, deadline reminders, workload organization, or other measures appropriate to the employee’s actual limitations. Document both sides of the process: the performance concerns and expectations, as well as the employer’s accommodation inquiries, proposed measures, employee responses, and follow-ups. The employee also has responsibilities in this process, including providing reasonably necessary information about restrictions or limitations, participating in discussions and cooperating with efforts to identify accommodation. If necessary information is repeatedly requested and the employee does not cooperate, that can eventually affect the extent of the employer’s accommodation obligation—but I would document several clear attempts before reaching that conclusion.

        Finally, keep medical/accommodation information separate from ordinary performance documentation wherever practical and tightly restrict access. A manager generally needs to know what accommodation is being provided and what expectations apply, not the employee’s medical details. The OHRC specifically recommends that medical information be kept confidential and, where possible, separately from the personnel file, with HR communicating functional restrictions to supervisors rather than diagnostic details. Given the intersection of disability accommodation and potential discipline here, Ontario employment/human-rights counsel should review the PIP and accommodation correspondence before the organization moves toward significant discipline or termination.

        I hope this helps.
        -HRInsider Staff

        Haley O’Halloran
        Keymaster
          Post count: 264

          You are correct that there is a balance between an employer’s duty to accommodate under human rights legislation and an employee’s corresponding duty to participate in the accommodation process. Where an employee is absent for medical reasons, the employer is generally entitled to request reasonable information necessary to understand whether the absence is medically supported, the employee’s functional limitations or restrictions, and, where possible, the anticipated duration of the absence or a timeframe for reassessment. The employee would not ordinarily be required to disclose a specific diagnosis unless there are exceptional circumstances that make that information reasonably necessary.

          Given that more than two months have passed and several reasonable deadlines have apparently been missed, the next step would typically be to provide the employee with a clear written request outlining exactly what information is still required, a final reasonable deadline for providing it, and the consequences if the information is not received. The communication should acknowledge that there may be legitimate reasons for delays in obtaining medical documentation and invite the employee to advise you promptly if they are experiencing difficulty meeting the deadline. It is also important to document the requests, deadlines, responses, and any explanations provided by the employee, as this demonstrates the employer’s continued efforts to obtain the information necessary to assess and support the leave.

          If the employee continues to communicate but does not provide the required information or a reasonable explanation for being unable to obtain it, you may eventually be in a position to advise that you cannot continue to substantiate or administer the absence as a medically supported leave without appropriate documentation. However, I would exercise caution before moving directly to discipline or termination, particularly if a disability may be involved. The applicable employment standards and human rights requirements should be reviewed for your province, and given the length of the absence and repeated non-compliance, obtaining legal advice before taking a step that could affect the employee’s employment would be prudent. The absence of a formal medical-leave policy does not necessarily prevent you from requesting reasonable supporting information, but implementing a consistent written policy going forward would help establish expectations and ensure similar situations are handled consistently.

          -HRInsider Staff

          Haley O’Halloran
          Keymaster
            Post count: 264

            An employer’s duty to address workplace harassment does not depend on whether an employee chooses to file a formal complaint. Under Ontario’s Occupational Health and Safety Act (OHSA), once an employer becomes aware—or ought reasonably to be aware—of potential workplace harassment, it has a legal obligation to take appropriate steps to assess and respond to the situation.

            In this scenario, the employer has been informed that an employee experienced unwanted touching and comments from a coworker and that other female employees may have had similar experiences. Even though the employee later indicated that she did not want to pursue the matter, these allegations are serious enough that the employer should not simply ignore them. An employer that fails to act after becoming aware of potential harassment could face legal and regulatory consequences if similar incidents occur in the future.

            A formal complaint from the affected employee is not required for an employer to investigate. The employer should assess the information available, consider the seriousness of the allegations and whether there may be an ongoing risk to others, and determine whether a workplace harassment investigation or preliminary fact-finding process is appropriate. If the employee chooses not to participate, the employer should respect that decision as much as possible while explaining its obligation to maintain a safe workplace.

            The supervisor should document what was disclosed, report the concern to HR or the individual responsible for workplace harassment matters, and avoid promising complete confidentiality, as an investigation may be necessary. Depending on the circumstances, the employer may also need to implement interim measures to protect employees while the matter is being assessed.

            Check out our harassment investigation policy and workplace harassment investigation checklist.

            -HRInsider Staff

            Haley O’Halloran
            Keymaster
              Post count: 264

              While there is no legal requirement to wait until an employee has resigned before discussing a potential independent contractor arrangement, it is generally a prudent risk management practice to keep the employment decision separate from any future contracting opportunity. If a contract role is offered at the same time the employee is advised that their remote work request has been denied, it may create the impression that the employee was encouraged or pressured to leave employment in exchange for continued work.

              Separating these decisions helps demonstrate that the remote work request was assessed solely on the organization’s operational needs and Remote Work Policy, and that any decision regarding the employee’s continued employment was made independently of a potential contractor relationship. It also reduces the risk of allegations that the resignation was not truly voluntary, that the employer was attempting to avoid its obligations under employment standards legislation, or that the contractor arrangement was simply a continuation of the employment relationship.

              Once the employment relationship has ended, the organization can assess whether there is a legitimate business need to engage the individual as an independent contractor for specific projects or deliverables. Treating the contractor engagement as a separate business decision helps support a clear distinction between employment and independent contracting, reduces worker classification risk, and demonstrates consistent application of the organization’s employment, procurement, and contractor engagement policies.

              Haley O’Halloran
              Keymaster
                Post count: 264

                The employee’s request for a permanent remote work arrangement should be assessed and communicated based solely on your organization’s operational needs and Remote Work Policy. If the request cannot be approved, clearly explain that the position requires work to be performed from the approved work location and that the existing terms and conditions of employment remain unchanged.

                If the employee chooses to relocate and is therefore unable to continue working under those existing terms, ask them to confirm whether they intend to continue their employment as currently structured. If they are unable or unwilling to do so because of the move, the employment relationship would end through the appropriate process, such as a voluntary resignation. If they instead begin working remotely without authorization, this should be addressed through your normal performance and disciplinary processes rather than being accepted by default.

                Once the employment relationship has ended, you may discuss the possibility of engaging the individual as an independent contractor for specific projects, events, or deliverables. This contractor arrangement should be clearly separate from their employment and structured as a genuine independent contractor relationship, with project-based work, defined deliverables, and appropriate contractual terms. Separating the employment decision from any future contracting opportunity helps reduce legal risk and supports compliance with your organization’s policies and applicable employment laws.

                I hope this helps!
                -HRInsider Staff

                Haley O’Halloran
                Keymaster
                  Post count: 264

                  Where an employee works on a public holiday and receives regular wages for the hours worked together with a substitute day off with public holiday pay, the hours worked would generally continue to be treated as hours worked for the purposes of an overtime averaging arrangement. If the employee instead receives public holiday pay plus premium pay for the hours worked, those premium-paid hours are excluded from overtime calculations under the ESA.

                  -HRInsider Staff

                  Haley O’Halloran
                  Keymaster
                    Post count: 264

                    Based on the approach you’ve described, it is helpful to distinguish between the employee’s statutory holiday entitlement under the Employment Standards Act (ESA) and the additional earned-time recognition provided through your averaging system. Assuming eligible employees receive their paid statutory holiday in accordance with the ESA, there would generally be no requirement to provide an additional day off in lieu simply because they were scheduled to be on call, provided they did not actually work on the holiday. The enhanced 0.75-day on-call credit would be an employer-provided recognition benefit acknowledging the added inconvenience of remaining available on a statutory holiday, rather than a statutory entitlement.

                    For purposes of your averaging model, it would be reasonable to continue entering the employee’s regular 7-hour statutory holiday credit to reflect the paid holiday, regardless of whether they perform additional work that day. If the employee travels for work or performs work on the statutory holiday, those hours could then be tracked separately as irregular or additional work under the averaging system, consistent with how you are accounting for other work performed outside the normal schedule. This approach maintains a clear distinction between the paid statutory holiday itself, which is a separate employment standards entitlement, and the additional work or availability that your averaging system is designed to recognize. As always, if employees actually work on a statutory holiday, you should also ensure the applicable ESA requirements regarding public holiday work—including entitlement to premium pay and/or a substitute holiday where applicable or any exemptions that may apply—are satisfied independently of your internal averaging policy.

                    Haley O’Halloran
                    Keymaster
                      Post count: 264

                      The short answer is that, on its own, this is unlikely to be enough to justify a termination for cause.

                      Whether an employee can engage in outside employment while on a stress leave depends on the specific circumstances. In some cases, working elsewhere during a medical leave may be consistent with the employee’s medical restrictions. However, if the outside work is inconsistent with the reason for the leave, or if the employee misrepresented their ability to work, it may raise legitimate concerns and warrant further investigation.

                      In this situation, several additional facts would need to be considered before determining whether discipline—or termination—is appropriate. For example:

                      -What were the employee’s medical restrictions while on leave?
                      -Was the mobile mechanic work similar in nature and physical demands to their regular duties?
                      -Did the employee have approval or disclose the outside employment, if required under company policy?
                      -Was there any conflict of interest, competition with your business, or misuse of confidential information or company resources?
                      -Is there evidence that the employee was capable of performing their regular job while claiming to be unable to work?

                      In most cases, an employer should conduct a thorough investigation before making any disciplinary decision. If the evidence demonstrates dishonesty, fraud, or a significant breach of the employment relationship, termination for cause may be considered. However, the legal threshold for just cause is high, and employers should proceed cautiously.

                      I hope this helps, let me know if you have any more questions.
                      -HRInsider Staff

                      Haley O’Halloran
                      Keymaster
                        Post count: 264

                        The most defensible approach under Ontario employment standards principles is to distinguish between being on call and actually performing work while on call. Since the purpose of your averaging system is to recognize irregular work and earned time rather than to track every scheduled hour worked by salaried employees, a fixed credit for carrying the on-call phone can reasonably be treated as a recognition benefit that acknowledges the inconvenience and restrictions associated with being available to respond.

                        Maintaining a fixed weekly on-call credit, such as the current 3.5-hour credit, is generally supportable provided it is clearly characterized as recognition for availability rather than a measure of hours worked. Employees are required to remain reachable, monitor the phone, and be prepared to respond within the required timeframe, even if no calls are ultimately received. This recognizes the burden of being on call without treating the entire on-call period as working time.
                        However, where employees actually perform work outside their regular schedule while on call, it is advisable to separately track and credit that time in addition to the fixed recognition credit. This better reflects the purpose of the averaging system and avoids situations where an employee who receives no calls receives the same credit as an employee who spends several hours responding to incidents or troubleshooting after hours.

                        With respect to statutory holidays, there is generally a reasonable basis for providing additional recognition when an employee is required to remain available during a holiday, even if no calls are received. The requirement to stay reachable and potentially interrupt personal or family plans can be viewed as a greater inconvenience than being on call during a regular workweek. As a result, an enhanced recognition credit, such as the current 5.25-hour credit, can be justified as acknowledging that additional burden rather than compensating for hours worked.
                        Overall, the most defensible model is one that combines a fixed recognition credit for the on-call assignment, an additional recognition credit where a statutory holiday falls within the rotation, and separate tracking of any actual work performed while on call. This clearly distinguishes availability from working time, aligns with the intent of the averaging system, and provides a fair and transparent method for recognizing both the obligation to remain available and any work that is actually performed.

                        -HRInsider staff

                        Haley O’Halloran
                        Keymaster
                          Post count: 264

                          Under the British Columbia Employment Standards Act (ESA), employees do not have to complete a probationary period before becoming eligible for most statutory leaves. Probation is an employer policy or contractual term and is not an eligibility requirement under the ESA.

                          Similarly, employees do not have to be permanent or regular employees to qualify for statutory leaves. Fixed-term, temporary, casual, and part-time employees are generally entitled to the same statutory leaves as permanent employees, provided they remain employed when the leave begins and meet any leave-specific requirements.

                          For most statutory leaves—including pregnancy, parental, bereavement, family responsibility, compassionate care, domestic or sexual violence, jury duty, and reservists’ leave—there is no minimum length of service required. Eligibility is based primarily on the employee meeting the circumstances that give rise to the leave rather than how long they have been employed.

                          The main exceptions are certain illness-related leaves, which require employees to have completed 90 consecutive days of employment before becoming eligible. Overall, unless a specific leave includes a service requirement, statutory leave entitlements under the BC ESA apply regardless of probationary status or whether the employee is employed on a permanent or fixed-term basis.

                          -HRInsider staff

                          Haley O’Halloran
                          Keymaster
                            Post count: 264

                            Although the employee has exhausted their job-protected leave under the applicable employment standards legislation, that does not necessarily end your obligations. If the employee’s injuries amount to a disability under human rights legislation, the employer continues to have a duty to accommodate to the point of undue hardship. The focus should therefore shift from statutory leave entitlements to the accommodation process. It is appropriate to maintain regular communication with the employee while requesting reasonable medical information needed to determine their fitness to return to work or whether additional leave remains medically necessary.

                            In this situation, the employee has already provided a Functional Ability Form clearing them to return to work but has since advised that ICBC has recommended additional medical clearance from their sports medicine physician. As a best practice, I would allow a reasonable amount of time for the employee to obtain this documentation before making any employment decisions. You may wish to confirm in writing that the employee remains on a medical leave pending receipt of the updated information and provide a reasonable deadline for submitting the documentation. If delays continue, maintain communication with the employee to understand the reason and determine whether additional time is warranted.
                            The anticipated surgery should be treated as a separate accommodation issue rather than as a question of whether the employee has remaining statutory leave available.

                            If the surgery and recovery period are medically supported, the employer should assess whether an additional unpaid medical leave is a reasonable accommodation. The absence of employer-sponsored LTD benefits does not affect the duty to accommodate, although it may impact the employee’s income replacement options. The key is to base decisions on current medical information rather than assumptions about the employee’s future ability to work.

                            Overall, your approach should be to continue engaging in the accommodation process, request only the medical information reasonably necessary to assess fitness for work and any restrictions, and document all communications. Provided the employee is actively cooperating and making reasonable efforts to obtain the requested medical information, granting additional time is generally the most defensible course of action. If, at some point, the employee stops communicating or is unable to provide sufficient medical information after reasonable opportunities have been given, you would then be in a better position to assess what further steps, if any, may be appropriate.

                            -HRInsider Staff

                            Haley O’Halloran
                            Keymaster
                              Post count: 264

                              The ASD diagnosis is a relevant mitigating factor, but it is not automatically a determinative one. Under Canadian human rights law, autism is a disability, and once an employer becomes aware of it, the employer has a duty to consider accommodation to the point of undue hardship. However, the duty to accommodate does not excuse misconduct simply because it may be connected to a disability. The key question is whether the disability affected the employee’s ability to understand the impact or wrongfulness of the conduct, to regulate their behaviour, or to comply with workplace expectations. Even if it did, the employer must still ensure a workplace free from harassment and sexual harassment.

                              When determining proportionate discipline, it is helpful to distinguish between culpability and risk. Factors supporting mitigation include the respondent’s documented diagnosis, remorse, admissions to three of the four allegations, willingness to cooperate, any evidence that the behaviours were influenced by ASD-related social communication deficits, a previously clean disciplinary record (if applicable), and whether accommodations might reasonably reduce the likelihood of recurrence. Factors supporting more severe discipline include the seriousness of the harassment, the impact on the complainant(s), whether the conduct was repeated or deliberate, whether there was an abuse of power, whether the respondent understood the conduct was unwelcome, and whether continued employment would undermine workplace safety or trust.

                              The fact that the you did not know about the diagnosis before the investigation is also significant. An employer cannot be criticized for failing to accommodate a disability it was unaware of. Your obligation arose once the disability was disclosed, and it appears you appropriately addressed accommodations during the investigation. The disciplinary decision should therefore be based on the misconduct itself, while considering the newly identified disability as one factor among many—not as a shield from accountability.

                              If the investigation supports that the misconduct can likely be prevented through reasonable accommodation and the respondent demonstrates insight, remorse, and a genuine commitment to change, alternatives to termination could include a lengthy unpaid suspension, a final written warning, mandatory respectful workplace and sexual harassment training, individualized coaching, accommodations informed by medical information (where appropriate), and a clear last-chance agreement stating that any further harassment will result in termination. Conversely, if the conduct was sufficiently serious, created an ongoing safety risk, or there is no reasonable basis to believe accommodation would prevent recurrence, termination may still be a proportionate response despite the ASD diagnosis.

                              Overall, the diagnosis should prompt a careful individualized assessment rather than an automatic reduction in discipline. The decision should be well documented, demonstrating that the employer weighed the disability, considered whether accommodation could address the behaviour going forward, and balanced those considerations against its legal obligation to provide a workplace free from harassment and sexual harassment. That approach is generally the strongest position from both an employment law and human rights perspective.

                              You can further navigate this matter by exploring some of these available resources:
                              How to Create a Mental Disability Accommodations Policy
                              Verifying Disability Policy
                              Accessibility Resources
                              Workplace Harassment Policy
                              Respectful Workplace Policy
                              Harassment – Know The Laws of Your Province

                              I hope this helps!
                              -HRInsider Staff

                              Haley O’Halloran
                              Keymaster
                                Post count: 264

                                No. An employee who qualifies for statutory severance pay (5+ years of service and the employer meets the payroll or mass termination threshold) is not automatically entitled to continued health and dental benefits during the statutory severance pay period.

                                One important caveat —

                                If the employee is receiving:

                                -common law reasonable notice,
                                -salary continuance under an employment contract, or
                                -an enhanced severance package,
                                the employer may agree (or be required) to continue benefits beyond the ESA minimums. That obligation comes from the employment contract, settlement agreement, or common law—not from the ESA’s statutory severance provisions.

                                So, under the ESA alone, benefits continue through the statutory notice period, but not through the statutory severance pay period.

                                -HRInsider Staff

                                Haley O’Halloran
                                Keymaster
                                  Post count: 264

                                  In Canada, employers should generally avoid asking applicants directly about their citizenship, permanent resident status, or immigration status unless there is a bona fide occupational requirement or a legal requirement to verify work authorization. Those questions could reveal a protected ground under human rights legislation and create a risk of a discrimination claim if not handled carefully.

                                  Instead, focus on the essential requirements of the position. Since successful enrolment in the CPA articling program is a legitimate job requirement, you can advise candidates that enrolment in the CPA program is a condition of employment and ask whether they are able to meet that requirement. For example: “This position requires successful enrolment in the CPA Professional Education Program (PEP) in accordance with CPA requirements. Are you able to meet this requirement by the required start date?” This keeps the discussion focused on the job requirement rather than the applicant’s citizenship or immigration status.

                                  If a candidate indicates they may be unable to meet the enrolment requirement, you can ask job-related follow-up questions, such as whether they anticipate any barriers to enrolling by the required deadline or whether they already meet CPA admission requirements. You should avoid probing into why they cannot enroll if the answer would require them to disclose protected information, such as their citizenship or immigration status.

                                  Finally, if the inability to obtain a Provincial Attestation Letter means the individual cannot satisfy an essential requirement of the role despite being legally authorized to work in Canada, the employer can generally make hiring decisions based on the inability to meet that bona fide occupational requirement—not on the individual’s citizenship or immigration status itself. Given the evolving nature of the Provincial Attestation Letter requirements, it would also be prudent to review your recruitment process with legal counsel to ensure your screening questions remain compliant with the applicable provincial human rights legislation.

                                  -HRInsider Staff

                                Viewing 15 posts - 31 through 45 (of 264 total)